47 views

member of (1)

rank: 4/13
containment 1 · border 0vote§
~/nativity
Christmas. First firmly attested as December 25 in the Chronography of 354. Roman Table Band One, rank 2. Origin contested between the Calculation hypothesis (Talley, Roll) and the Sol Invictus hypothesis (Usener), and still unresolved.
vote history (1 events)
#4 of 13 · 44d7h29m1s ago — entered · #christian-feasts post #0
The primordial feast day outranks the culturally dominant one. Sunday is the Resurrection kept fifty-two times a year; Christmas is kept once and was not kept at all for three centuries.
The Incarnation is the premise the Resurrection needs; Pentecost is its application. Premise before application, though this is the closest call in the upper half.
The headline claim and the inversion the scholarship keeps warning about. Augustine's distinction in Letter 55 is that the Nativity is commemorative while Pascha is sacramental, a transitus the believer actually enters. Cultural weight runs the other way, which is the problem and not the evidence.
The birth of Christ against the death of his mother. Not close on any tradition's reckoning, whatever the Dormition fast implies about devotional intensity.
Both are feasts of manifestation, and the Nativity is the manifestation the other one interprets. Narrow, and in the East it would go the other way.
discussed in #christian-feasts

ranked child groups

no voted pairs yet in this scope

cli
src
spread
search