~/consensus-or-coercionDid lopsided conciliar majorities record settled belief or fear of exile? Nicaea was near-unanimous and its holdouts were banished — but the fifty years following were dominated by Arian ascendancy and Athanasius was exiled five times. A vote that one-sided which then failed to hold for two generations is evidence against reading conciliar unanimity as coercive closure. What eventually settled Nicaea was not the count. It was the reception.
~/no-jamnia-councilThe “Council of Jamnia” closing the Jewish canon is a modern reconstruction, not an event securely attested by ancient sources. Rabbinic texts preserve disputes over books such as Ecclesiastes and Song of Songs, including whether they “defile the hands,” but no synod selecting and sealing the Tanakh. As with Nicaea and the New Testament, a tidy council story replaces a longer history of differentiated use, argument, and stabilization.
no votes on this pair in this scope yet
you’ll log in, then return to this pair to cast your vote.
~/no-jamnia-council0.429 · 2p~/no-vote0.429 · 2p~/real-contest0.143 · 2p~/consensus-or-coercion · unranked